🐐 Holiday special:
🐐 Holiday special: The Greenhouse annual plan is 25% off through December 1, right before our December series, By Another Road, begins. Give yourself an early gift for a kinder, gentler Christmas. (Goatie approved.)
There’s a moment at a lot of Thanksgiving tables. Someone taps a glass, smiles, and says, “Let’s go around and share what we’re thankful for.”
And your stomach drops.
Because this year was hard. Maybe your faith changed and the people at that table noticed. Maybe there’s an empty chair. Maybe you’re grateful for some things and grieving others, and you’re not sure which one is going to come out of your mouth.
Pass the rolls. Quickly.
One year, as we were setting the table for Thanksgiving dinner, my then mother-in-law told me it was a sin for a woman to be a pastor. I was so flustered, I didn’t know what to say when we went around the table talking about what we were thankful for. It was too hard to come up with anything to say, so I muttered something about family and passed the torch to someone else.
A lot of us were taught that gratitude is a rule. Good Christians are thankful. Always. If you’re sad, you’re not trusting God enough. If you’re struggling, you should count your blessings. And there was a verse for it.
This week I want to look at that verse closely, because I think it says something much kinder than we were told.
The verse we were given
“Rejoice always; pray without ceasing; give thanks in all circumstances, for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you.”* (1 Thessalonians 5:16–18)
Many of us heard that as: no matter what happens, put on a smile. Lost a job? Give thanks. Lost a parent? Give thanks. Lost your community because you asked honest questions? Give thanks, and stop being so negative.
That isn’t gratitude. That’s pretending. And pretending wears a person out.
Look at who Paul was writing to
The Thessalonian church was small, new, and under pressure. People in their town were hostile to them (1 Thessalonians 2:14). Some of their loved ones had died, and they were afraid those people were lost forever.
And here’s the part we skipped. Just one chapter earlier, Paul writes to them about their dead: “we do not want you to be uninformed… so that you may not grieve as others do who have no hope” (4:13). Notice what he doesn’t say. He doesn’t say, “Don’t grieve.” He says don’t grieve without hope. He assumes they’re grieving. He expects it.
The same letter that says “give thanks in all circumstances” makes room for tears.
“In,” not “for”
Now look closely at one small word. Paul says to give thanks in all circumstances. In Greek, en panti: in everything, in the middle of whatever is happening.
He doesn’t say to give thanks for everything. You don’t have to be thankful for the harm, the loss, the betrayal, or the way someone treated you when your faith changed. You’re invited to find something true to be thankful for while you’re in it.
That’s a completely different request. One asks you to pretend the hard thing is good. The other asks you to notice that the hard thing isn’t the only thing.
What biblical gratitude actually sounds like
If you want to know how gratitude works in Scripture, read the psalms. Psalm 13 opens like this:
“How long, O LORD? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me?”* (Psalm 13:1)
That’s not polite. That’s raw. And the psalmist doesn’t skip it or tidy it up. Four verses of honest complaint. And then, at the very end:
“I will sing to the LORD, because he has dealt bountifully with me.”* (Psalm 13:6)
The complaint and the thanks are in the same prayer. Neither one cancels the other. That’s what gratitude looks like in the Bible: not a mask over grief, but a small light held up inside it.
A word worth defining
Bless. This whole mini-series is anchored in Psalm 103, which opens, “Bless the LORD, O my soul, and do not forget all his benefits” (103:2). The Hebrew word for bless, barak, is connected to the word for knee. To bless is something like to kneel, to lower yourself and pay attention. Gratitude, in that sense, isn’t a performance. It’s a slowing down. A noticing. Do not forget the good that is really there.
You can kneel and notice the good with tears on your face. The psalmists did it all the time.
An honest complication
Someone will point out that Ephesians goes even further: “giving thanks to God the Father at all times and for everything” (Ephesians 5:20). For everything?
That line comes in a passage about worship, about believers singing together. It isn’t a command to thank God for abuse, injustice, or harm. The same Paul who wrote it also wrote that he was “so utterly, unbearably crushed that we despaired of life itself” (2 Corinthians 1:8). He didn’t pretend. Scripture never asks you to call evil good. It invites you to find God with you in the middle of everything, and to say thank you for that.
And one more honesty. If you can’t find anything to be grateful for right now, that’s okay too. Gratitude isn’t a test you’re failing. Sometimes the most faithful prayer you can pray is the “How long?” part. God can wait for the rest.
So what do we do with this
Let both be true. Try saying it out loud: “I’m grateful for ___, and I’m grieving ___.” You don’t have to pick one.
Go small and specific. Not “I’m thankful for everything.” Just one true thing. The coffee. The dog. The friend who texted.
Take your gratitude to God, not just to the table. Tell God the hard part and the good part, the way the psalmist did. That’s prayer.
You don’t have to fake thankful this year. You’re allowed to show up to the table with both hands full.
God who stays in the “how long,”
here is my grief, and here is my one small thanks.
Hold them both for me. Amen.
The Greenhouse Preview
🐐 Holiday special:
🐐 Holiday special: The Greenhouse annual plan is 25% off through December 1, right before our December series, By Another Road, begins. Give yourself an early gift for a kinder, gentler Christmas. (Goatie approved.)
This Friday in The Greenhouse: what to do when the “go around the table” moment comes, and a grounding practice you can do right there in your chair.
The Closing Question
What’s one small, true thing you’re thankful for this week, even if everything else is hard?
P.S. This Sunday on Streams of Grace: how to give thanks with both hands full. Come breathe with me.Sign up here!



Your messages come with perfect timing. Thank you!